While a good definition of
multicultural education is simply, “Multicultural education incorporates the
idea that all students - regardless of their gender, sexual orientation, social
class, and ethnic, racial, or cultural characteristics - should have an equal
opportunity to learn in school,” (Banks, p. 3) all that those words entail
are complex.
I have been teaching for
over 20 years, and multicultural education has come to mean different things.
When I first did my student teaching, I would say the school district thought
it was doing well because it occasionally celebrated different heritages. It
most certainly was a “tourist-based approach.” (Banks, p. 26) In today’s
classroom, we have come a long way but still have a long way to go.Being a multicultural classroom or school or
district means examining and changing everything from policies, curriculum, assessment,
delivery styles and every other aspect of our instruction and reach.
Because I teach Adult
Education and ESL students, my classroom is diverse in every possible
way. My students have ranged in age from 16 to 67, a multitude of ethnicities
and refugees, immigrants, and international students from many different
countries. It is easy to see them as their background or their country or even
their gender or skin color.A
multicultural educator sees the big picture. They recognize the beauty in
uniqueness and diversity. And they celebrate all within the classroom community
as individuals and as a whole.
The video, “The Danger of a
Single Story,” by Chimamanda Ngozi Adichie (below) moved me to consider how I
approach their learning and their participation. Do I view them differently as
they are from “third-world countries?” Do I ask different questions and in
different ways because they come from underprivileged areas and schools? Do I
assume their ability to retain deeper concepts because of their background or
criminal history? Do I contribute to the racial or individual gap in
learning? (Lee, p.3)
As teachers, we should
constantly be striving for multicultural classrooms. And as Lee states, “Multiculturalism
is the ideal state in which people’s culture, language, heritage and humanity
are fully valued.” (p.4)
I had a substitute one day
who had no experience with the unique population I teach and he made a
comment that they should be able to do a certain skill because it was “second-grade
level concepts and they obviously either couldn’t handle that or they couldn’t
understand the material because of a language barrier.” Needless to say, he no
longer substitutes for our department or college.
What he assumed about my
students was that they were either 1) not smart enough to finish school and
that is why they had dropped out or 2) they could not understand English enough
to accomplish the task. He was seeing them as a single story. What
he (and many people) assume about students in Adult Education, is that they are
not capable or lazy or uneducated. But in my experience, that is not the single
story of any of them. They are in their situation due to circumstances,
either outside their control (like parent drug-use, health issues, or even
government violence in their own country) or from poor life choices they are
trying to fix.
What struck me from the
video, and also my classroom, is that the single-story way of thinking can
change how the person views themselves. And that, in turn, will affect every
aspect of their lives, including their level of education.
Banks, J. & McGee Banks, C. (Eds.) (2016).
Multicultural education: Issues and
perspectives. Hoboken, NJ: Wiley.
Lee, E., Menkaret, D. & Okazawa-Rey, M.
(1998). Beyond Heroes and Holidays: A Practical Guide to K-12 Anti-Racist,
Multicultural Education and Staff Development. Washington, D.C.: Teaching for
Change.
I have seen the "Danger of a single story" video before, but it is always a great reminder to remember that students come from all different walks of life and may be dealing with things that we may not fully understand. I think it's easy to get caught up in a binary mindset much like the substitute in your example. It's not as simple as a student understanding a concept or not grasping it, a student being absent or present for class, or behaving vs. acting inappropriately. There are lots of gray areas that sometimes we don't understand. We must constantly ask ourselves if there is a perspective we are not seeing, or something else we can do to guide our students. This is why establishing a relationship with our students is so critical.
I have seen the "Danger of a single story" video before, but it is always a great reminder to remember that students come from all different walks of life and may be dealing with things that we may not fully understand. I think it's easy to get caught up in a binary mindset much like the substitute in your example. It's not as simple as a student understanding a concept or not grasping it, a student being absent or present for class, or behaving vs. acting inappropriately. There are lots of gray areas that sometimes we don't understand. We must constantly ask ourselves if there is a perspective we are not seeing, or something else we can do to guide our students. This is why establishing a relationship with our students is so critical.
ReplyDelete